더 버지 갤럭시 S10 리뷰

미국의 IT 미디어로 유명한 더 버지에서 갤럭시 S10의 리뷰를 유튜브에 올렸습니다.

이번 리뷰로 벌써부터 사람들의 지지와 반대가 양측으로 달아오르며 극명한 호불호를 보이는 상황인데요.

과연 더 버지가 갤럭시 S10 플러스에 대해 뭐라고 리뷰했길래 이렇게 시끄러운 걸까요?

우선 유튜브에서 더 버지의 리뷰를 검색하면 아래와 같이 나옵니다.

제목이 Samsung Galaxy S10 Plus review : the anti-iPhone 입니다.

제목이 아이폰 중심의 느낌이네요.

한국어로 해석하자면 아이폰 대항마 정도 되겠습니다.

영상 아래 있는 더 버지의 description을 보면 이렇게 적혀 있습니다.

The Galaxy S10 Plus is easily the best Android phone you can buy right now. It took Samsung a few years to hit its stride with high-end hardware, and the past Galaxy S phones have been considerably better, if a bit predictable. This year’s Galaxy S10 family is no different: these are high-end phones with cutting edge technology, strong battery life, sleek designs, and a versatile camera system.

일단 기존 대비 별 차이점이 없다고 까고 시작하는군요.

더 버지 갤럭시 S10+ 리뷰

본론으로 들어가 유튜브 내용 공유 드리겠습니다.

아래는 유튜브 영상에 나오는 대사 원문입니다.

혹시 부분적으로 확인하고 싶은 내용이 있으시면 참고 하시기 바랍니다.

It's hard to believe that it's been almost 10 years since Samsung released the first Galaxy S smartphone,

but here we are with the Galaxy S10, and it's easily the best Galaxy S yet.

But if the first few Galaxy phones were close copies of the iPhone,

enough so much that Apple actually sued Samsung and won,

the Galaxy S10 shows that Samsung has evolved its flagship to offer almost everything the iPhone doesn't.

It's got a headphone jack, expandable storage, fingerprint scanner, and almost no notch.

You could practically call it the anti-iPhone.

But it does share some things with the iPhone, like the fact that it's expensive. 

The S10 starts at $899, the S10 Plus that I have here starts at $999 and goes all the way up to 1600 bucks.

That's like three basic model OnePlus 6Ts.

This may be the best Galaxy S phone ever, but it's also far and away the most expensive Galaxy S phone ever.

(upbeat music) 

The S10's hardware is very nice.

It's exactly what you'd expect for a phone that costs this much.

It's an evolution of what Samsung started four years ago with the Galaxy S6.

Has aluminum sides with a polished finish, and front and rear glass.

Now, on the S10 and the S10 Plus, the glass curves into the frame, which makes it feel great in your hand and more comfortable to hold, even though these are really big phones.

Now, on that point, the S10 Plus is definitely  not a one hand phone, not for me at least.

If I were to purchase it, I'd probably put a case, and maybe even one of those PopSockets on the back to make it easier to hold and use.

If you do want something smaller, Samsung has a regular S10, and then the S10e which we're going to cover in a separate video, so stay tuned for that.

Now, like I said before, there's a headphone jack down at the bottom, Samsung actually includes some pretty nice wired headphones that plug right into it.

Plus, loud stereo speakers for when you're not wearing headphones.

Like the last few Galaxy S models, the S10 is water resistant, has fast wired and wireless charging, and you can expand the storage with a microSD card, though I think most people will probably be pretty happy with the 128 gigs it comes with in the base model.

You can even use the S10 to wirelessly charge another device like Samsung's new Galaxy Bud headphones, or Galaxy Watch Active smartwatch, but I really have found much use for that beyond just showing it off.

The big annoying thing with the S10's hardware is the same as it has been for the last few Samsung phones.

There's a hardware button dedicated to launching Bixby.

Now fortunately, Samsung is going to let you finally reprogram it to something more useful, like say maybe launching the camera.

But sadly, you can't use to launch the Google Assistant.

And this is all I'm going to say about Bixby, because it's still bad, and you should still avoid it if possible.

Inside, the S10 is the first phone I've used with the Snapdragon 855 processor, and performance is really fast.

It's smooth and responsive, and there's no real lag anywhere.

I don't think it's as blisteringly fast as a OnePlus phone, but I've got no real performance complaints here.

I also don't have any complaints with the battery life.

I don't think the S10 Plus is breaking any records, but it's reliable enough that I just don't have to worry about it.

I've been able to get two days between charges with light usage, and have no real trouble making it a full day with heavy usage.

But it is a big phone, with a big battery, so this is the kind of battery life that I kind of expect at this point.

(upbeat music) 

The S10 Plus's display does not disappoint.

It's a 6.4 inch HDR10+ OLED screen, that gets super bright, and has rich, vibrant colors and great viewing angles.

The screen stretches all the way to the top and bottom of the phone, with just the tiniest of borders around it.

Now, Samsung seems to have toned down its super aggressive saturation this year, so the normal video mode, which is what I use this screen in, looks really pleasing, and not eye searing, like it used to.

But, that isn't particularly new or exciting.

What is exciting is what's embedded in this display.

As you probably already noticed, the S10 doesn't have a notch cut out for its front facing camera.

Instead, it has this weird hole punch shape off to the right side.

On the S10 Plus, that houses two cameras, the main camera, and second one for depth effects and portrait mode.

Is this any better than a notch which would just be in the middle of the screen instead of off to the side?

I don't really think so.

In fact, I would rather have a notch since at least that has some symmetry.

This hole punch design pushes the battery and network indicators off to the left, and it just looks weird when I'm looking at it all day long.

You can choose to hide the front cameras entirely with a uniform black bar across the top, but that's just like adding a giant bezel to the top, and looks even worse.

Sometimes, that black bar shows up depending on which app you're using.

Here's what it looks like when I read an article in Pocket, for example.

None of this is the end of the world, the S10's display still looks really nice, and it's probably one of the best actual panels you can get on a phone.

I'd just rather have a notch in the middle, but I'm sure you'll let me know in the comments if you disagree.

The other thing that's embedded in the screen is the new fingerprint scanner which has been moved from the back of the phone up to the front.

The scanner's ultrasonic, which is a little different from the optical ones we've seen on OnePlus and other phones.

That's supposed to make it a bit more reliable and harder to spoof.

It can be hard to find, but it's about half an inch up from the bottom, and if you're using a lock screen it'll actually show you where to place your finger.

But it's not a big area, and if you're not deliberate with your finger placement, it can be easy to miss.

And this scanner is definitely not as fast as traditional capacitive ones, and I often have to try a couple of times before it will unlock.

I'd just rather have a Face ID system that requires less work to use, or at the very least, and old school fingerprint scanner on the back of the phone.

Now, the S10 does have a face unlocking feature, but you should know that it's just using the camera to look for your image.

There's no 3D mapping, or advanced scanning.

So it's not as secure as the fingerprint scanner, or Apple's Face ID.

I was actually able to unlock it with a video of my face played on another phone, so there you go.

(hip hop music) 

Here's the main takeaway you should know about the S10's camera.

It is perhaps the most versatile of any of the mainstream phones.

That's because the S10 has three cameras on the back, which give you different perspectives at the click of a button.

There's a standard camera, a telephoto camera, and then a brand new ultra-wide camera.

It's like having a whole camera bag full of lenses built right into the back of your phone, and it lets you capture perspectives, especially that super wide one that you just can't get with an iPhone or a Pixel.

One weird thing to note about this, though?

The S10's portrait mode uses the main camera instead of the telephoto, so your portrait shots are going to come out pretty wide, maybe wider than you expect.

It's kind of like how the iPhone XR works, as opposed to the XS.

Now, aside from the new lens, the camera performance really hasn't changed much from last year's S9 Plus.

The S10's camera is still very good, with fast focusing, fast launching, and generally great performance in most lighting situations.

But if you didn't like the way the photos from the S9 looked, you probably aren't going to be swayed by the S10.

Personally, I find it overexposes more than I prefer, which does make for a brighter image, but it sometimes causes things like skin tones to look unnatural.

It also has a warmer look than the iPhone, and especially the Pixel, which can make images look a bit more yellow than I like.

Now, for HDR, Samsung basically splits the difference between the iPhone and the Pixel.

It's not as moody as Google's phone, but it doesn't pull up shadows as much as Apple's does.

And that's partly because it doesn't really need to, because it's already overexposing the shot more than Apple would.

Samsung has added some new software tricks to the camera.

It has a feature that will help you compose your shots better, which is kinda cool, because it can help you avoid crooked lines in your photos.

But, I didn't end up using it all that much.

It also does have a night mode, but unlike the Pixel, you can't just turn it on whenever you want.

You need to be in a really dark area, less than one lux of light, and be using the scene optimizer mode for it to trigger, and even if you do all that, it still doesn't work as well as Google's Night Sight anyways Over on the video side though, the S10 is way more sive than the Pixel and even gives the iPhone a run for its money.

You can shoot in up to 4K, 60 frames per second with the main camera, or 4K, 30 FPS with the ultra-wide, or the telephoto.

There's a new super steady stabilization feature that makes really smooth footage, but just know that will lock you to 1080p and the main camera when you turn it on.

Finally, the stereo sound that's recorded by the dual mics on the S10 is actually quite good, and better than what I'm used to hearing from most other Android phones.

For the front camera, the new 10 megapixel sensor with autofocus produces really sharp images, and there's even a software button to get a little bit wider of a view if you're shooting a group selfie.

Now, Samsung does do some pretty aggressive noise reduction and skin smoothing, especially in low light, but thankfully, the beauty modes are all turned off by default.

Then there's the portrait mode on the S10 Plus, it's pretty decent, but it's not perfect, just like any other portrait mode you can get on any other phone, and there's a couple of new effects that you'll probably use once, and then never touch again, kinda like Apple's portrait lighting stuff.

For many years, Samsung phones have always had super tempting hardware that was let down by lousy software.

I'm happy to say that's not the case with the S10.

Its software isn't perfect, and I definitely have some complaints, but overall, it looks nice, makes sense, and is mostly easy to use.

Samsung's calling this software One UI, and it's also now available on last year's S9 phones, which my colleague Dieter just did a video about, so you should go check that out, but the gist is Samsung has finally built software that works with its big phones.

It has designed much of the user experience to make it easier to use these giant screened phones by putting a lot of the important stuff down by your thumb, so you don't have to reach to the top to get it.

But I'd still like to see more improvements.

I ended up using the default three button nav bar instead of Samsung's gestures, because they're just kind of confusing.

There're also still a bunch of duplicate apps, like two email apps, two app stores, two browsers, et cetera, and so on.

I wish Samsung would just let me choose which ones to install when I'm setting up the phone.

Plus, I've been using an unlocked model, so you can expect carriers to make this even worse with their own apps.

Is anyone ready for VZ Messenger?

And the main nagging question with Samsung software is how long is it going to take to get updates?

Google's going to release Android Q sometime later this year.

And you'll probably have to wait another half a year or more before it arrives on the S10, if last year's schedule is anything to go by.

(drum music) 

It's easy to dismiss the S10 as just another Galaxy phone without anything really new or groundbreaking, and you'd really not be that wrong.

After all, Samsung itself is going to release a crazy folding phone in like, two months, and the S10 is just another slab smartphone like we've had for years.

But this is the Android phone that more people will buy than any other, and it provides as strong an alternative to the iPhone as you can find.

It really comes down to personal preference.

Are you so married to iOS and iMessage that you'll never leave?

Or are you looking for something that has features that you just can't get on the iPhone?

If you're the latter, well then the S10 is here for you.

Likewise, if you're debating between the S10 and a Pixel, the question is how important are software updates and night photography to you?

If those things aren't very high on your list, the S10 is better than a Pixel in virtually every other respect, and finally, if you're wondering whether or not the S10 Plus is worth nearly double the cost of a OnePlus 6T, your money will go towards a better display, better speakers, waterproofing, wireless charging, and a much better camera.

That might be enough stuff to make it worth it, provided you actually care about all of those things.

It's been 10 years since the first Galaxy S phone, and it's clear that Samsung has come a long way.

Now, I'm curious to see, where's it gonna go in the next 10 years?

Hey, thanks for watching.

For more on the S10, the S10 Plus, and the S10e, be sure to check out theverge.com.

We've got way more info in our written reviews on the site, if you really wanna dive into these.

Let me know what you think about the S10 Plus, and what do you wanna know about the S10e?

We're gonna be tackling that one next.

더 버지의 갤럭시 S10 플러스에 대한 주요 리뷰 내용을 보면 다음과 같습니다.

더 버지 갤럭시 S10 리뷰 정리

1. 삼성이 택한 카메라 홀 방식보다 노치 디자인이 훨씬 낫다.

2. 화면 지문인식 방식보다 Face Id가 훨씬 좋다.

3. 카메라도 아이폰이 더 좋다.

4. 아이폰을 쓰지 않는다면, 안드로이드 폰 쪽에서는 제일 나은 제품이다.

5. 고로 아이폰이 최고다.

저는 평소 아이폰이나 안드로이드폰 혹은 그 중에서도 삼성 안드로이드폰 중 어느 게 훨씬 낫다고 판단하긴 어렵다고 생각을 가지고 있습니다.

왜냐하면 크게 보면 같은 스마트폰이지만, 자세히 보면 양 제품간 추구하는 바가 조금씩 차이가 있고 그 부분에 의해 장단점이나 호불호가 갈리기도 합니다.

그렇기에 이용자 각자 성향에 맞는 제품을 고르는 것이 중요하고, 어느 쪽이 더 좋다 나쁘다 할 때는 각 기능이나 특징 면에서 기준을 잡고 '이러저러해서 이 분야에서는 이 제품이 더 좋다' 라는 근거를 가지고 말하는 것이 중요한데, 이번 더 버지의 갤럭시 S10 플러스를 리뷰하면서 아이폰을 비교한 발언들은 전부 근거가 없는 개인 취향 고백에 가깝다는 느낌이 들었습니다.

그래서 이번 더 버지의 리뷰에 대해 이런 판단을 내렸습니다.

이건 그냥 IT 매체 하나가 돈이 벌고 싶어서 노이즈 마케팅 마냥 분란을 일으킨 리뷰이다. 라고 말입니다.

근래 2년여간 더 버지가 편집장을 바꾸고 나서 중립 성향의 리뷰들을 내면서 사업성이 많이 떨어졌다고 합니다.

이에 무언가 결단을 내리고 다시 예전과 같은 모습으로 돌아간 것이 아닐까 생각됩니다.

정확한 사정은 더 버지만이 알겠지요.

아무튼 이런 유명한 매체에서 단순히 난 이게 더 좋아! 같은 식의 리뷰보다는 좀 더 논리적이고 디테일한 리뷰를 내줬으면 하는 바람입니다.

이상 더 버지의 갤럭시 S10 플러스 리뷰 내용 및 시청 소감을 마치겠습니다.